Our Favorite Gifts

With over 500 products in our spice cabinet, gifting can get overwhelming. That’s why we compiled a list of our favorites to make it easier. From sweet tooth to meat tooth, modest to magnificent, we have gift suggestions for all tastes and textures.

As you consider who on your list has been naughty or nice, we have a few ideas for the nice people:

Free Shipping on Select Gift Boxes

Shipping is free on these gift boxes, so send as many as you need. We will write your gift message by hand using our stellar penmanship.

Read more…


Hot Cocoa Collection

This new cocoa collection is everything we hoped it would be. It includes Classic, Hazelnut, Masala, and Salted Caramel. Your favorite mug not included.

Read more…


The Best Sellers

These are our all-time top sellers: Lake Shore Drive, Back of the Yards, Vulcan’s Fire Salt, and Gateway to the North. These are the Beatles of spice blends.

Read more…


Exquisite: The Spice Trader

For the most special cook on your list, this collection includes 12 of our most wonderful and exotic products from all around the world.

Read more…



The Fully Scented Gift Card

This gift card is packed with spices, so it smells the part. Packing spices include cloves, bay leaves, and a cinnamon stick. We will write your custom gift message by hand.

Read more…



24 Essential Spices

These are the essential spices we would hope to find in every kitchen. Perfect for the serious cook or anyone needing full spice rack replacement.

Read more…


And for the naughty people:

2 Oz Bag of Salt Dust

This modest bag of salt dust is perhaps our most unremarkable product. It makes a gentle statement while also being somewhat useful.

Read more…



2 Oz Bag of Pepper Dust

Pepper dust is a ubiquitous byproduct of the spice trade. We grind a lot of pepper and that produces a lot of dust. It is nasty stuff and not that useful.

Read more…


Check our Staff Favorites and New Products collections for more inspiration.

Favorite Fall Recipes

When I was asked to write about favorite hearty fall meals, I had just returned from New Mexico where local markets and roadside stands were celebrating a new harvest of chile peppers. Red and Green…

Spices for Sailors & Marines

An extra special spice shipment left our warehouse earlier this week. 252 jars of premium spices are bound for Sailors and Marines aboard the aircraft carrier USS Harry S. Truman. Spice House customers from 29…


    I would like to give my sis-in-law a gift card…but don’t know her email…we both have been to your Milwaukee store & also enjoy penzeys…she does use messenger on fb …could you send it to me & i’ll print ,that way I can wrap it????

    Hi Gloria,

    Of course we can.

    You can place an order online for our Gift Card Package.

    Just use your home address for the shipping address and it will get sent to you.

    The gift card package even includes a blank card for you to fill out with any message you’d like.

    Does this help?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *